Major Impact Players Shy Of The 500 Points Club
| PLAYER | CLASS |
|---|---|
| Scott Ruth | 2000 |
| Jeff Clark | 2000 |
| David Enzweiler | 2000 |
| Nick Ziegler | 2001 |
| Jon Lloyd | 2001 |
| Brett Riley | 2005 |
| Steven McCarthy | 2005 |
| Adam Franzen | 2006 |
| Bryan Niemeyer | 2007 |
| Matt Lloyd | 2007 |
| Kyle Kramer | 2007 |
| Nathan Mutsch | 2007 |
| Jordan Armstrong | 2010 |
| Joe Jennings | 2012 | Erik Rieger | 2014 |
| Jake Jennings | 2014 | Jon Zink | 2015 |
| Joey Hickman | 2016 |
| Robbie Verst | 2022 |
| Luke Schumacher | 2023 |
| Anthony Kruse | 2023 |
Basketball Mustangs At College
| PLAYER | CLASS | COLLEGE | SPORT(S) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dave Scheibly | 1981 | Meridian Jr. College (Miss.) / NKU | Basketball / Golf |
| Ryan Horan | 1997 | Cincinnati State | Basketball |
| Nathan Seiter | 1998 | NKU | Basketball |
| Justin Seiter | 2000 | Morehead State / NKU | Baseball |
| Chris Ryan | 2001 | Morehead State | Basketball |
| Kevin Smith | 2005 | Hawaii-Pacific | Basketball |
| Ryan Anderson | 2005 | Vincennes Jr. / Georgetown | Baseball |
| Troy Cooper | 2007 | Cincinnati | Track |
| Nathan Mutsch | 2007 | Xavier | Baseball |
| Jon Lloyd | 2007 | Belmont | Soccer |
| Zach Hertzenberg | 2008 | Brescia | Baseball |
| Jacob Rieger | 2010 | Hanover | Basketball |
| Joe Jennings | 2012 | Transylvania | Basketball |
| Alex Trentman | 2014 | Christian Brothers | Basketball | Drew Burns | 2014 | Centre | Basketball |
| Jackson Crawford | 2016 | Hanover | Basketball |